18 votes
Accepted

Should Magic The Gathering have it's own StackExchange?

Good question! There are reasonable criteria for suggesting that Magic should have its own Stack Exchange — such as a desire to attract a community of Magic-focused players who don't identify ...
Alex P's user avatar
  • 29.5k
18 votes
Accepted

Should we burninate [mtg-history]?

Yes, let's burninate it. It's redundant, and we can & should tag MTG history questions as magic-the-gathering history.
doppelgreener's user avatar
18 votes

Alice, Bob, and Carol — Should we encourage using placeholder names for the players?

Leave it up to the asker how people are represented in their question - be that with names, numbers, or game specific terms (AP/NAP for MtG; BB, LB, BTN, etc for poker) - If anything I would ...
Andrew's user avatar
  • 14.5k
17 votes

Accepting nominations for a replacement moderator!

I would like to nominate myself (parent profile, meta profile). I have participated in community moderation of this site and of Arqade (main profile, meta profile) for several years. I am an active ...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
17 votes
Accepted

Why the recent addition of MTG sub tags?

There's more than that: I've also created mtg-double-faced-cards, mtg-competitive-rel, mtg-professional-rel, mtg-regular-rel, mtg-color-identity, and mtg-emblems. The rationale is that our MTG tag ...
doppelgreener's user avatar
15 votes
Accepted

Should MTG card links be added to more than the first instance of the card name?

I am more in favour of only Linking the first instance of the card as per Wikipedia standards. One thing that I find when looking at questions or answers that have every instance of a card linked, is ...
Malco's user avatar
  • 7,672
15 votes
Accepted

Should we keep [combat]?

This tag doesn't sound like it is one that will have any experts in it as combat is different in many games. I would recommend removing this tag.
Joe W's user avatar
  • 14.1k
14 votes

What syntax construct should be used for rulebook quotes?

Any time you're quoting more than one line of someone else's text, you should use a block quote. If you really need custom indentation, you can represent that part of the quotation as a code block ...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
14 votes
Accepted

Is it acceptable to ask for the rules or instructions to an obscure board game?

This is perfectly acceptable as finding the rules for a board game is on topic even if it is an obscure one. The fact that you have done some searching on your own is also good as it shows you are not ...
Joe W's user avatar
  • 14.1k
14 votes
Accepted

Are card recommendation questions on-topic?

I think they should be (& remain) on topic. These questions are generally well-scoped and are about achieving a specific functional purpose within a game. For card games like Yu-Gi-Oh, Pokemon, ...
doppelgreener's user avatar
13 votes
Accepted

identify-this-game that might exist (but probably doesn't)

I think it should be closed and the asker should consult Anime & Manga Stack Exchange instead. We can't really help them very effectively. It's worth noting that media regularly makes up games ...
doppelgreener's user avatar
13 votes
Accepted

Unpinning the accepted answer

I would strongly support making this change. The elevation of the accepted answer is primarily valuable in situations where the asker is in a unique position to evaluate the answer differently than ...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
12 votes

How often should a certain term in a question/answer be linkified?

Your edit did more than just add links - you fixed other issues with the post. I cannot say the same of the next edit. I would love to hear why two high reputation users approved an edit that adds ...
Rainbolt's user avatar
  • 13.7k
12 votes

Are well-defined theoretical or custom Magic questions on-topic?

I am generally in favor of questions about custom Magic cards. They're interesting ways of exploring nuances in the rules, and that's valuable especially with rules as complex as Magic's. I think ...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
12 votes

Are chess questions on-topic here?

It has always been the philosophy of the StackExchange network that determining whether a topic is on topic should be done on a purely per-site basis, without considering whether the topic is on topic ...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
12 votes
Accepted

Why have the tag [timeline-cheapass-games] instead of renaming it [timeline]?

There's another game called Timeline that's more widely known (nearly 1000 reviews on BoardGameGeek, sold at mass-market stores) that's not by Cheapass Games. I can't find a BoardGameGeek page for ...
Cascabel's user avatar
  • 26.9k
12 votes
Accepted

Where would questions about the lore of a board or card game go?

Lore questions on here are fine by current policy. They are also on topic for Sci-Fi & Fantasy SE as long as the game has science fiction or fantasy elements; SFF has a MTG tag. You may ask on ...
doppelgreener's user avatar
12 votes

Why do contributors with no experience with trick-taking card games insist on closing questions on such games?

There are two entirely separate things going on here: was it correct to close this question, and general policy about who should and shouldn't close questions. It seems you've decided that the answer ...
Cascabel's user avatar
  • 26.9k
11 votes

How do we feel about questions about leaked Magic cards?

I don't think we should close all such questions. However, I think we should be very mindful of how we handle them: Use spoiler block quotes (>!) - at the very least for card text/images. (Images ...
Cascabel's user avatar
  • 26.9k
11 votes

How should we handle silver-bordered (Unstable) rules questions?

We should answer to the best of our abilities, using available resources if possible (the FAQ, Mark Rosewater's social media rulings, and anything else similarly "official"), and our best reasoning ...
Cascabel's user avatar
  • 26.9k
11 votes

Are legal questions on topic?

I'd strongly prefer that legal questions (of either category) be off-topic. I get that people are interested in such questions, and it'd be cool to get actual answers. But although legal questions ...
Cascabel's user avatar
  • 26.9k
11 votes

Graduating from Beta: generating more questions per day

There are a couple of issues that may be fundamental obstacles to improving our long-term question volume, that we have to take into account when considering potential solutions to the problem. First,...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
11 votes

Congratulations, you're no longer in Beta!

We won the longest beta award! Can we have a gold beta badge now :P. O wait, the longest road only adds 2 victory points.
Toon Krijthe's user avatar
  • 11.8k
11 votes

Alice, Bob, and Carol — Should we encourage using placeholder names for the players?

As long as the post is clear about which player does what, it should be fine, and does not warrant an edit. This can be achieved by naming the players A, B, C, D; or Timmy, John, and Keith; or Red, ...
ilkkachu's user avatar
  • 912
10 votes
Accepted

What is the meaning of [designer-board-games]?

I think we should get rid of the tag. It refers to the distinction between mass-market board games (Monopoly, Clue, etc) and less widely published/sold board games. Think of things that might ...
Cascabel's user avatar
  • 26.9k
10 votes

Downvoting other answers to increase vote ratio with self answer

Just let it go. Upvotes and downvotes happen, and the only thing you can do about it is post quality content to encourage people to upvote. You shouldn't flag it. People are free to vote how they ...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
10 votes
Accepted

Should game-adjacent questions be on-topic?

The fact that a board game exists about a topic doesn't mean that a question about that topic is the same as a question about the game. When I think of Pokemon; I think of a series of video games that ...
GendoIkari's user avatar
10 votes
Accepted

Should new board games be self contained in the post?

Just go right ahead and ask about your question, and make sure to name which game it is. Including tons of extraneous rules about the game and gameplay would only act to obscure your actual question, ...
doppelgreener's user avatar
10 votes

Should we keep [specific-card]?

No, the tag specific-card should not exist. The purpose of a tag is to label a category or topic that someone would either search for or watch. This tag does not do any of that, so it should be ...
murgatroid99's user avatar
  • 82.4k
10 votes
Accepted

Should we keep [specific-card]?

No, specific-card should be removed. The tag "specific card" divides all questions on the site into two categories: questions about a specific card, and questions not about a specific card. Neither ...
BJ Myers's user avatar
  • 4,571

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible