Let's try to nail this down and get some consensus on these questions and move forward. I've definitely got some thoughts of my own, but I'd love to hear everyone else's.
For reference, if you mouse over the up/down arrows you'll get the standard guidance for all stackexchange sites.
- Up - This question is useful and clear
- Down - This question is unclear or not useful
- Up - This answer is useful
- Down - This answer is not useful